Body mass index, or BMI, is probably the number your doctor’s system calculates most often about you. It’s quick, free and needs only a scale and a tape measure. But you’ve probably also heard that it’s “outdated” or “doesn’t work for muscular people”. Both views have some truth in them. BMI is a reasonable rough guide across large groups of people, and a much less reliable one for a single person.
This article explains where BMI came from, what research shows about how often it gets people wrong, and which simple measures, especially waist-to-height ratio, can fill the gaps. It’s part of our complete guide to how to lose weight, based on the evidence.
This article is for general information and isn’t medical advice. Body measurements are screening tools, not diagnoses. If you’re worried about your weight or health risk, talk to your doctor. If you have a history of disordered eating, a clinician can help you decide whether tracking body measurements is useful for you at all.
In this article:
- What BMI Is, and Where It Came From
- How Accurate Is BMI?
- Where BMI Goes Wrong
- Why Waist Size Matters
- Waist-to-Height Ratio: The Simple Upgrade
- How to Measure Your Waist Properly
- What About Body Fat Percentage?
- How Doctors Are Changing the Way They Use BMI
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Key Takeaways
What BMI Is, and Where It Came From
BMI is your weight in kilograms divided by your height in metres squared. For most adults, the standard categories are:
- Under 18.5: underweight
- 18.5 to 24.9: healthy weight
- 25 to 29.9: overweight
- 30 or above: obesity
The formula goes back to the 1830s and the Belgian mathematician Adolphe Quetelet. He was trying to describe the “average man” for his statistical work, not to judge anyone’s health. It was renamed “body mass index” in 1972, when physiologist Ancel Keys and colleagues compared several weight-for-height formulas in more than 7,000 men in the Journal of Chronic Diseases. Keys found it to be the best of the options available at the time, but considered it suited to studying populations rather than assessing individuals. That distinction still matters today.
How Accurate Is BMI?
The fair test of BMI is how well it identifies people who actually carry too much body fat. Two large analyses give a consistent answer.
A 2010 systematic review and meta-analysis by Okorodudu and colleagues in the International Journal of Obesity pooled 25 studies covering nearly 32,000 people. It compared standard BMI obesity cutoffs with direct body-fat measurements. BMI had a specificity of about 90%: if BMI said you had obesity, you very likely did carry excess fat. But its sensitivity was only about 50%. In other words, BMI missed around half of the people who had excess body fat.
A 2008 study by Romero-Corral and colleagues, also in the International Journal of Obesity, found the same pattern in 13,601 US adults from the national NHANES survey, using body-fat estimates from bioelectrical impedance. A BMI of 30 or more was good at ruling people in, but missed more than half of those with excess body fat. Accuracy was weakest in the middle BMI ranges, in men and in older adults.
So BMI tends to fail in one particular direction. A high BMI is usually a real signal. A “normal” BMI is less reassuring than it looks.
Where BMI Goes Wrong
BMI only knows your weight and height. It can’t tell muscle from fat, or where on your body the fat is stored. That creates a few predictable blind spots.
Muscular people
Muscle is dense, so a strength athlete can have a BMI in the “overweight” range with relatively little body fat. This is the most famous criticism of BMI, but it applies to a fairly small group of people. As the studies above show, the bigger problem in the general population is the reverse.
Older adults and “normal-weight” fat gain
As people age, they tend to lose muscle and gain fat, often without much change on the scale. Their BMI can stay in the healthy range while their body composition shifts in a less healthy direction. That’s part of why BMI performs worse in older adults.
Ethnic background
People of different ethnic backgrounds carry different amounts of fat, and different risk, at the same BMI. The UK’s National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) recommends lower thresholds for people of South Asian, Chinese, other Asian, Middle Eastern, Black African or African-Caribbean family background: overweight from a BMI of 23, and obesity from 27.5. NICE notes that people of South Asian and Chinese background showed increased risk at BMIs of around 21 to 26, compared with 25 to 29 in people of white background. It also notes that the evidence for some groups, particularly Black African and Caribbean populations, is limited.
Fat location
Two people with the same BMI can carry fat very differently. Fat stored deep in the abdomen around the organs (visceral fat) is more strongly linked with type 2 diabetes and heart disease than fat stored on the hips and thighs. BMI can’t see the difference, but a tape measure can. We cover why belly fat in particular matters in our article on belly fat and inflammaging.
Why Waist Size Matters
The strongest evidence for adding a waist measurement comes from the EPIC study, published by Pischon and colleagues in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2008. It followed 359,387 adults in nine European countries for an average of almost 10 years.
BMI was linked with risk of death, with the lowest risk around a BMI of 25 for men and 24 for women. But waist size added information that BMI didn’t. Even after accounting for BMI, people in the highest fifth for waist circumference had about twice the risk of death of those in the lowest fifth among men (relative risk 2.05) and about 1.8 times the risk among women (1.78). The authors concluded that waist circumference or waist-to-hip ratio should be used alongside BMI, not instead of it.
Commonly used waist cutoffs, based on World Health Organization guidance, are:
- Men: increased risk at 94 cm (37 in) or more; substantially increased risk at 102 cm (40 in) or more
- Women: increased risk at 80 cm (31.5 in) or more; substantially increased risk at 88 cm (34.5 in) or more
Lower cutoffs are often used for some Asian populations. The weakness of a single waist cutoff is that it ignores height. A 91 cm (36 in) waist means something different on someone who is 155 cm tall than on someone who is 190 cm tall. That’s the gap waist-to-height ratio fills.
Waist-to-Height Ratio: The Simple Upgrade
Waist-to-height ratio is your waist measurement divided by your height, using the same units for both. The rule of thumb is simple: keep your waist to less than half your height.
NICE first recommended this in 2022, and it’s part of its current obesity guideline. NICE uses these bands for adults:
- 0.4 to 0.49: healthy, no increased health risk
- 0.5 to 0.59: increased central adiposity, increased health risk
- 0.6 or more: high central adiposity, further increased health risk
For example, someone 170 cm tall would aim for a waist under 85 cm. NICE encourages adults with a BMI below 35 to measure their own waist-to-height ratio. Above a BMI of 35, health risk is already high and the ratio adds less. It also isn’t meant for use during pregnancy. The ratio is meant to be used alongside BMI, not to replace it.
The research case for it comes from a 2012 systematic review and meta-analysis by Ashwell, Gunn and Gibson in Obesity Reviews. It compared how well BMI, waist circumference and waist-to-height ratio picked out adults with cardiometabolic risk factors such as diabetes, high blood pressure and abnormal cholesterol. Waist circumference improved on BMI by about 3%, and waist-to-height ratio by about 4–5%. Waist-to-height ratio was also significantly better than waist circumference alone for diabetes, high blood pressure and cardiovascular disease in both men and women. Those are modest improvements, not a revolution. But the measure costs nothing and takes a minute.
How to Measure Your Waist Properly
Most home measurements go wrong because the tape is in the wrong place. The standard method is:
- Find the bottom of your ribs and the top of your hip bones.
- Wrap the tape around your middle at the point halfway between them. For many people that’s roughly level with the belly button, but not always.
- Breathe out naturally and measure. Don’t suck your stomach in or pull the tape tight.
- Measure against bare skin or thin clothing, and use the same method each time.
Divide that number by your height. If you’re tracking change over time, measure about once a month at the same time of day. Waist size moves much more slowly than daily scale weight, and it’s less affected by water swings, which is useful during a weight-loss plateau when the scale seems stuck.
What About Body Fat Percentage?
Measuring body fat directly sounds like the obvious fix, and in research settings it is. DEXA scans are the usual reference method. But the tools most people have at home are much less precise.
Smart scales and handheld devices estimate body fat using bioelectrical impedance, sending a weak current through the body. Their readings can shift noticeably with hydration, meals and exercise, and individual estimates can be off by several percentage points. We looked at the evidence in detail in our article on how accurate smart scale body fat readings are. The short version: the trend over weeks is more useful than any single number, and a tape measure is often just as informative for everyday purposes.
How Doctors Are Changing the Way They Use BMI
Medical bodies are moving away from using BMI on its own, though not abandoning it.
In June 2023, the American Medical Association adopted a policy describing BMI as an imperfect clinical measure. It recommends using BMI alongside other measures of risk, such as waist circumference, body composition, visceral fat and metabolic factors. The AMA also said BMI loses predictive power at the individual level, shouldn’t be the sole criterion for denying insurance reimbursement, and can lead to underdiagnosis of eating disorders when relied on too heavily.
In January 2025, a commission published in The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology, chaired by Francesco Rubino and endorsed by more than 75 medical organisations, went further. It proposed that excess body fat should be confirmed with more than BMI alone, such as a waist measurement or direct body-fat measurement. It also split obesity into two categories. “Clinical obesity” is excess fat that is already impairing how organs and tissues work, or limiting daily activities. “Preclinical obesity” is excess fat with raised future risk but no current illness. The idea is to focus treatment, including the newer GLP-1 weight-loss drugs, on the people most likely to benefit.
The practical upshot is the same as the research above: BMI is a starting point, and a waist measurement is the simplest way to add the context it lacks.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is BMI accurate?
It’s reasonably accurate for groups of people and when it’s high, but less reliable for individuals. A 2010 meta-analysis of about 32,000 people found standard BMI cutoffs correctly flagged excess fat about 90% of the time when they said obesity, but missed around half of people who actually had excess body fat.
What is a healthy waist-to-height ratio?
NICE says to keep your waist to less than half your height, a ratio under 0.5. A ratio of 0.4 to 0.49 is considered healthy, 0.5 to 0.59 indicates increased health risk, and 0.6 or more indicates further increased risk.
Is waist-to-height ratio better than BMI?
For predicting cardiometabolic risk, it does slightly better. A 2012 meta-analysis found waist-to-height ratio improved on BMI by about 4–5% for picking out people with risk factors like diabetes and high blood pressure. Guidelines recommend using it alongside BMI rather than instead of it.
Can you have a normal BMI and still be unhealthy?
Yes. BMI can’t see body composition or where fat is stored, so someone with a normal BMI can still carry excess fat, especially around the abdomen. This is more common in older adults. A waist measurement can help pick it up.
Why are BMI cutoffs lower for Asian people?
Research shows people of South Asian and Chinese background, among others, tend to develop diabetes and heart disease risk at lower BMIs. NICE therefore uses an overweight threshold of 23 and an obesity threshold of 27.5 for people of South Asian, Chinese, other Asian, Middle Eastern, Black African or African-Caribbean family background.
Key Takeaways
- BMI was designed to describe populations, not individuals, and it can’t tell muscle from fat or show where fat is stored.
- A high BMI is usually a real signal, but BMI misses around half of people with excess body fat, so a normal BMI is less reassuring than it seems.
- Waist size predicts health risk even after accounting for BMI. In a study of over 350,000 Europeans, the largest waists carried roughly double the risk of death in men.
- Waist-to-height ratio is a simple upgrade: aim to keep your waist under half your height.
- Home body-fat readings are imprecise. Trends over weeks, and a tape measure, are more useful than single readings.
- Major medical bodies now recommend using BMI together with other measures, not on its own.
For more on diet, exercise, sleep, medication and keeping weight off, see our complete guide to how to lose weight, and our article on how to keep weight off.

